Otie's Tavern & Grill Hilliard
Otie's Tavern & Grill Logo

Otie's Tavern & Grill

@oties_tavern

4.01686 reviews

Otie's Tavern & Grill offers a casual spot for food and drinks in Hilliard, Ohio. Nestled at 5344 Center St, this place combines a grill, pub, and bar with a welcoming atmosphere. Great for lunch or dinner, it emphasizes local specialties and quick service.

Famous for its amazing cocktails and vast beer selection, Otie's provides something for everyone. Notable items like the Otie's Fried Bologna and Blackened Shrimp Po' Boy catch many guests' attention. The bustling patio and friendly staff make it a go-to for gatherings and quick bites.

Sports events broadcast on big screens add to the lively vibe. Happy hour specials on food and drinks keep patrons coming back. Families will find a comfortable space with a kids menu and accessible facilities throughout the restaurant.

After a busy day, relax on the patio amidst blooming flowers and a soothing fountain, setting the perfect mood for a meal. With music events and showcases throughout the week, Otie's Tavern & Grill is a community favorite.

About

Otie's Tavern & Grill has been a part of Hilliard's vibrant dining scene for years. The establishment embodies the spirit of local culture with an emphasis on delicious cuisine and an inviting atmosphere. Significant renovations have refreshed the place.

Once frequented by families, Otie's continues to draw in visitors looking for quality food and drinks. The new ownership group has worked diligently to enhance the menu and maintain strong ties with the community. Regular events bring locals together for fun evenings filled with laughter and good company.

A crucial factor is the accessibility offered to all guests, making Otie's truly a family-friendly venue. The accessible parking and seating areas ensure everyone can enjoy the fantastic offerings. It has transformed into a hotspot, especially on weekends, with live music events and a friendly crowd.

Get in Touch

5344 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 12:00-23:00
  • Tuesday 12:00-23:00
  • Wednesday 12:00-23:00
  • Thursday 12:00-23:00
  • Friday 12:00-00:00
  • Saturday 12:00-00:00
  • Sunday 11:00-21:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Had an amazing Otie's Fried Bologna today! Added dill pickles, which I highly recommend and they were perfect!Delicious hand cut fries were amazing as well, very crispy! What a great environment! My buddy and I were the only ones there, no idea why, maybe busier in evening. We had lunch! I would like to see more down home food on the menu, like it used to be years ago. Today was great though."

- Jim W.

"Not a huge menu, but I wanted to try six or more items on it! I was able to narrow it down to three and the waitress told me I really should try the Cuban sandwich. It was a good sandwich, but I think a more substantial pickle was in order, and perhaps a more robust mustard. Everything else was spot on it was pressed the pork was good, the ham was good, it just needed a bit of a punch. I did really like the fries that came out on the plate. But take a look at the picture I post, they were all like little fried nuggets! Not gonna complain was able to finish them with a drizzle with the sauce and eat them with a fork! I would like to get a chance to get back and try the Reuben sometime in a couple of the appetizers and sounded especially good a very solid choice for lunch or an easy dinner."

- David T.

"This used to be such an awesome place to go to with our family. The food was great and friendly service and the patio out back is so relaxing with pretty flowers and a nice trickle sound from the fountain. It has changed. Tonight the gyro meat was not fresh. It was also completely over cooked. Along with that all the normal flowers out back were dead and just not the same level of care as before. We also got the green beans appetizer which used to be fresh but now the beans seem like they are frozen or out of a can not fresh at all. So sad to see this place fall to this level."

- Sarah S.

"Great pork belly!! Quick service, great staff and fun kids area to help entertain our little ones. The location was perfect and the atmosphere was well decorated. Will definitely be back!!"

- Lauren P.

"Thought we would check it out since it has a new owner. Do yourself a favor and stop in. The shrimp po'boy is amazing. The burger was huge. And the fried green beans are delicious! I should have taken a picture but I dove in as soon as I got it."

- Charles T.

"Update - Learned that there was new ownership and decided to try it one more time. I will say that the new ownership turned this around with the snap of a finger. The food was absolutely delicious and much improved. I had the Bourbon Burger and it was fantastic. Could tell it was served fresh - loaded up with toppings and hit the spot. French fries were excellent as well. The caprese salad we got was fresh and delicious. The chicken was cooked perfectly and tasted great. Will be coming back!"

- Patrick E.

"This was my first visit since the recent menu overhaul and general facelift. Kudos! The menu is very good. I had a Cubano sandwich and it was by far the best I've had in Columbus. Stacked with pulled pork, ham, melted Swiss, pickled onion, pickles and mustard on a fresh sandwich roll. One half was a meal, but it was so good I ate both and washed it down with a fresh, well poured Guinness."

- John P.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Otie's Tavern & Grill provides a delightful dining experience. Its casual ambiance is perfect for unwinding after a long day. The extensive drink menu offers a variety of choices, from cocktails to craft beer. Make sure to try the Caramel Apple Martini, a local favorite!

Expect fast service, even during busy periods. This restaurant stands out for its affordability, too, with dishes priced between $10 and $20. Weekdays from noon to 3 PM are ideal for a quieter atmosphere without the usual crowd.

The menu features both hearty entrees and light appetizers, making it versatile for any appetite. Patrons rave about the Otie's Charcuterie and Fried Green Beans. Families can enjoy the small kid's menu while adults indulge in sophisticated wine selections.

Another reason to visit is the community-oriented vibe. Local events often take place here, attracting regulars and newcomers alike. Whether it's Taco Tuesday or live music nights, every visit promises excitement. Enjoy time on the patio during the warmer months, surrounded by a friendly atmosphere.

Most Liked things

Guests rave about the Otie's Fried Bologna sandwich – a must-try for anyone! The hand-cut fries come highly recommended for their crispiness and taste. The bustling bar scene with quick service adds to the enjoyment.

A cozy patio area provides a delightful outdoor dining experience. Many appreciate the welcoming ambiance and engaging staff who make every visit special. Happy hour deals attract guests looking to unwind with friends.

Live music nights and events cultivate a fun, communal experience that many locals cherish. The mix of classic dishes like the Reuben and modern variations such as the Blackened Shrimp adds flair to the menu.

Most Disliked things

Some visitors express disappointment in occasional food inconsistencies, especially regarding freshness. On rare occasions, dishes may not meet the expected quality standards. Feedback often indicates a desire for more traditional home-cooked items on the menu.

While many love the variety, others feel the menu could be expanded further. A few guests mention experiencing slower service during peak hours, particularly on busy weekends. Occasional comments about the patio maintenance have also surfaced, though efforts are ongoing to enhance the atmosphere.

Some diners feel certain items could use more robust seasoning and flavor profiles. Addressing these concerns is vital to maintaining the restaurant's excellent reputation and appeal.

FAQ

What types of food does Otie's Tavern & Grill offer?

Otie's Tavern & Grill serves a variety of dishes. Enjoy appetizers like Otie's Charcuterie. They also have salads like Caesar and several sandwiches like the Blackened Shrimp Po' Boy. Don't miss their entrees like Fried Catfish.

Is there live entertainment at Otie's Tavern & Grill?

Yes, Otie's Tavern & Grill hosts live concerts and sports events. It's a great place to relax, have fun, and enjoy some local talent while sipping on a well-crafted cocktail.

What are the happy hour specials?

During happy hour, Otie's offers deals on select appetizers and drinks. Boudin Balls, wings, and fried green beans are some favorites.

Is the venue wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Otie's Tavern & Grill is fully accessible. It has wheelchair-friendly entrances, restrooms, and seating areas, ensuring a comfortable experience for everyone.

What’s a must-try cocktail at Otie's?

Try the Caramel Apple Martini. It’s a crowd favorite. The flavors are unique and make for a delightful drink after a long day.